My Workbench

Wednesday, May 1, 2024

Looking for Feedback

 I am just looking for some feedback in this post. How do these aircraft flight markers look?




Looking for constructive criticism 
Thanks


10 comments:

Jonathan Freitag said...

Vol, I really like the look of your triangular flight pattern. The contrast is good and the individual aircraft look 3D.

Lawrence H said...

They look great Vol. They give the appearance of a swarm of aircraft. Are they also 3D printed and then painted?

A Miniatures Hobby Room said...

They are Japanese Kate torpedo bombers. The flight below them are Aichi D3a dive bombers. The flights on the right are American Devastator torpedo bombers and below them are Avenger dive bombers

A Miniatures Hobby Room said...

Thanks Lawrence. No, the aren't 3D prints. I just downloaded silhouettes I found online, sized and grouped them in a Word doc, then printed them out. I glued them to some 1.5mm card stock and then cut them out. I glued sockets on the bottom, made from cutoff drywall screw anchors. The sockets fit the 3mm clear 2" peg stands I got from Litko.

A Miniatures Hobby Room said...

Do you think the contrast is very important? Some of the aircraft, especially the American planes, were blue and don't stand out as well against the aqua background.

Stew said...

Those will all work fine for gaming. But if you want my nitpicky opinion I especially like the one on the bottom left (first picture). I don’t like the triangle one just because the formation looks fake.
Contrast between plane and background matters, as the white planes really pop but the non white ones just look like smudges.

A Miniatures Hobby Room said...

Thanks for the feedback Stew. So one vote for the triangle formation and one vote against. Consensus against the blue American planes.

A Miniatures Hobby Room said...

What I'm attempting here: The IJN formations are different from the US. Within the specific navy, the torpedo, dive bomber, and fighter formations are unique. So there should be no confusion between American, Japanese, British, or German flights or the type of planes.
In the photo with the ships, upper right are Avenger dive bombers. Lower right are Devastator torpedo bombers. On the top left are IJN Kate torpedo bombers and below them are Aichi D3a dive bombers Each formation is different.

Anonymous said...

I think the plane formations are a near graphic idea, the US ones are maybe too camouflaged, maybe if they were a darker blue to stand out?
Best Iain

Lasgunpacker said...

Lured over to your blog by the HMS Vanguard (lovely!), and noticed this.

Maybe you could print them on a clear sheet instead of on paper (like for overhead projectors). Then the "camouflaged" planes would be more obvious than they are currently, but not very much more work on your end.